51 Taylor Island

FOR SALE
$1,499,000
51 Taylor Island, Gravenhurst
51 Taylor Island
51 Taylor Island
51 Taylor Island
51 Taylor Island
51 Taylor Island
51 Taylor Island
51 Taylor Island
51 Taylor Island
51 Taylor Island
51 Taylor Island
51 Taylor Island
51 Taylor Island
Browsing Limit Reached
Please Register for Unlimited Access
2 + 1
BEDROOMS
2
BATHROOMS
1
KITCHENS
10 + 1
ROOMS
X13494674
MLSID
Contact Us
Property Description
Timeless and full of character, this cottage is classic Muskoka at it's best! Nestled on a lush, tree-lined, gently sloping lot with nearly 2 acres & a generous 385 ft of shoreline, this exceptional property has it all. An abundance of flat outdoor space for family gatherings, lawn games & lakeside entertaining. Panoramic views & sought-after southwest-to-southeast exposure, sunshine all day, deep water off the dock & a sandy beach ideal for children. A refreshing cross breeze flows across the property, keeping the cottage naturally cool and the bugs away creating a comfortable outdoor setting throughout the summer. Spend evenings under the moon & stars around the lakeside fire pit, watch the kids enjoy the private play structure, or unwind in the expansive Muskoka room with vaulted ceilings and long unobstructed lake views. Inside, beautiful pine walls & ceilings throughout evoke warmth & charm. A spacious living & dining area centred around a fireplace, an eat-in kitchen, two bedrooms with walkouts to the large decks, two full bathrooms, and convenient laundry. A separate bunkie provides additional accommodation for family & friends. Enjoy the benefit of numerous recent updates, WiFi-enabled systems, and a 14kW backup generator that deliver modern convenience and peace of mind. As one of Muskoka's coveted Big Three Lakes, Lake Muskoka offers endless opportunities to explore by boat, with access to waterfront restaurants, iconic destinations, championship golf & miles of breathtaking shoreline. Just a one-minute boat ride from the marina, this property offers the perfect balance of privacy & convenience. The best part yet - The potential is endless with a lot this size supporting the potential construction of a 2 storey boathouse and/or the opportunity to add onto the cottage subject to municipal approvals. Furniture may be negotiable so you might enjoy this rare opportunity to own a turnkey family retreat on one of Muskoka's most iconic lakes.
Property Features
Lake/Pond, Marina, Waterfront, Wooded/Treed, Sloping, Clear View, Central Vacuum, Generator - Partial, On Demand Water Heater, Primary Bedroom - Main Floor, Water Treatment, Propane, Dock, Boat Slip
Property Details
Address
51 Taylor Island
Community
Postal Code
P1P 1R2
Property Type
Detached, Detached
Zoning
RW-6A
Lot Size
385' x 422'
Acreage
1.8 Feet
Taxes
$5,557 (2025
Basement
None
Heat Type
Baseboard
Heat Source
Electric
Water
Other
Garage Type
None
Listing contracted with Chestnut Park Real Estate
Similar Listings
891 Peninsula Road, Gravenhurst
3
BEDS
2
BATHS
$1,375,000
FOR SALE
Winter, Spring, Summer or Fall. Your own gated, year round playground on 12.93 picturesque acres. Sled, Skate, Canoe, ATV. This stunning bungalow has been reimagined into almost 1800 sq.ft. of luxury living. Completely redone in 2025 with something for everyone in the family.4 Minutes away from Muskoka Bay Resort & Muskoka Wharf & Bay. This open concept bungalow has everything you need. Open concept living/dining/kitchen area allows you to entertain all your friends and family. New kitchen with Caesarstone counter tops, pot filler over the stove and stainless steel appliances. The coffee bar presents more cabinet space and a usable workstation. The new living area is absolutely stunning with crown molding, lots of light and sliding doors to the new wrap around deck. The new main bathroom has full size laundry with Caesarstone folding station. The primary bedroom was designed with comfort and convenience with spa-like ensuite and designer walk in closet. This master retreat has sliding patio doors to the new glass railed deck. 2 additional bedrooms allow for the kids or guests to have their own space. There is much more too! The wrap around porch and deck offer 144 linear feet of space to explore and entertain. There are views from every part of the deck. New fire pit conversation area on solid granite lets you view the stars every night. The recently added 3 car detached garage ('24) is a home for all your daily drives. And if you have more toys to store, don't worry. There's an additional 30'x25' workshop/garage with concrete floor, heat, hoist and overhead door. Spend hours everyday on the many trails on your own property exploring all of nature's glory. Wild strawberries and blueberries can be found. Send the kids and guests on a quest. Spend some time reflecting by the giant inland pond or skipping stones. There's so much to explore & so many beautiful vistas that it's hard to put into words. There is a possibility of severance if one wants to explore that.
27 Island 2Ml, Gravenhurst
3
BEDS
2
BATHS
$1,449,900
FOR SALE
Nestled on over 2.2 acres of beautifully natural Muskoka landscape with an extraordinary 750 feet of pristine shoreline, this exceptional Cape Cod-inspired cottage on Morrison Lake offers a rare opportunity to experience waterfront living at its most private and picturesque. Surrounded by breathtaking lake views and mature natural surroundings, the property provides an unparalleled sense of peace, seclusion, and escape in the heart of South Muskoka. Custom built in 2005 with quality craftsmanship and timeless design, the cottage blends classic Muskoka charm with modern comfort. Warm and inviting interiors are complemented by high-end finishes and thoughtfully designed living spaces throughout. At the heart of the home, a stunning chef's kitchen with a large centre island creates the perfect gathering place for family and friends, while the open-concept living and dining areas are filled with natural light and showcase spectacular panoramic water views from nearly every vantage point. The cottage offers three generous bedrooms plus a versatile loft ideal for a home office, den, or additional sleeping accommodations. Two well-appointed bathrooms provide comfort and convenience, while a separate seasonal bunkie creates a private retreat for guests. Designed to embrace Muskoka's renowned outdoor lifestyle, the property features expansive decking, two covered porches, and an incredible all-season Muskoka room with retractable windows that invite the outdoors in and frame stunning waterfront vistas. Two private docks provide exceptional access to swimming, boating, and endless days on the water. Accessible by boat, this water-access-only property offers a level of privacy and tranquillity that is increasingly rare to find. Offering remarkable privacy, extensive shoreline, and an idyllic setting on one of South Muskoka's most sought-after lakes, this is a truly special waterfront retreat where unforgettable memories are made and cherished for generations.
1018 Georgina Way 2, Gravenhurst
3
BEDS
1
BATHS
$1,360,000
FOR SALE
BIG VIEWS | LAKE MUSKOKA COTTAGE + 2-Slip BOATHOUSE and DETACHED GARAGE at an Affordable Price! Enjoy stunning panoramic views over Muskoka Bay from this charming 3-season cottage in an excellent location west of Gravenhurst, just off Parkers Point Road. This property offers easy access to all the best Muskoka has to offer - a short drive to Gravenhurst's waterfront amenities, Wharf restaurants and shops, the town boat launch, historic steamship tours, and quick Hwy 11 access for GTA commuters. The gently sloping lot provides effortless waterfront access with minimal stairs, leading to 100 feet of frontage on approximately half an acre. A spacious double-slip boathouse protects your boats from the elements while offering plenty of additional docking space. Swim right off the dock in clear Lake Muskoka water! Inside, the cottage features 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and a loft for extra sleeping space. A mini-split heating and A/C system extends your comfortable enjoyment from early spring through late fall. Perfect for families or first-time Muskoka buyers looking for big views, great boating, and an affordable entry into a 'BIG THREE' Muskoka property to add your personal touch and updates!
1117 Turtle Lake Road, Gravenhurst
3
BEDS
1
BATHS
$1,249,000
FOR SALE
Welcome to your perfect Muskoka escape on the serene shores of Turtle Lake in Gravenhurst. Set on a level lot with 100 feet of waterfront, this charming three-bedroom cottage delivers the perfect year round cottage country experience. Just minutes from the shops, restaurants, and marina of beautiful downtown Gravenhurst, this property strikes the ideal balance between peaceful lakeside living and everyday convenience. Step inside to a bright, open-concept living space anchored by a wood-burning fireplace, finished with beautiful European craftsman woodwork throughout. Fully insulated for true year-round comfort, the cottage has been thoughtfully maintained with a new roof and all mechanicals new and upgraded. The kitchen flows seamlessly into the living area, making it a natural gathering space for family and friends. Three comfortable bedrooms, including a king primary and a fun triple bunk room, offer plenty of space for everyone. A fully equipped bunkie with two queen beds, heating, air conditioning, and a TV adds even more room for guests, comfortably sleeping 14. Outside, a large deck overlooks the water and serves as the perfect place to start and end the day. The level lot provides easy, effortless access to the water's edge, with a spacious new steel dock perfect for swimming, fishing, and launching into everything Turtle Lake has to offer. Whether you're looking for a personal retreat, a family gathering place, or a turn-key short-term rental opportunity, this Turtle Lake cottage checks every box. Properties like this - level, accessible, and move-in ready on a quiet Gravenhurst lake - don't last long.
1065 Kilworthy Road, Gravenhurst
3
BEDS
3
BATHS
$1,399,000
FOR SALE
Experience elevated living in this custom-built maibec sided bungalow located in Kilworthy with convenient access to Highway 11, offering easy travel north to Gravenhurst or south to Orillia. Thoughtfully designed with both style and functionality in mind, this 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home showcases quality finishes and exceptional craftsmanship throughout. The open concept kitchen and living area is highlighted by soaring 12-foot ceilings and a stunning 42" Napoleon fireplace with an impressive floor-to-ceiling stone surround, creating a striking focal point for the home. The well-designed layout places the primary suite privately on the opposite side of the home from the additional bedrooms, offering excellent separation and flow. The ensuite bathroom features premium Riobel fixtures and a heated floor for added comfort and luxury. Additional high-end features include Riobel bath and kitchen fixtures throughout, a GenerLink backup generator system for peace of mind, and a full-height unfinished basement with a partially completed bathroom, providing outstanding potential for future living space tailored to the next owner's needs. The insulated and heated 3-car garage offers excellent space for vehicles, hobbies, storage, or workshop use and also includes a 60-amp rough-in for a future EV charger, the 9' by 8' Doors make getting in and out easy for all sizes of toys. Outside, the professionally hardscaped and landscaped 1.2+ acre property was finished with new sod last fall, creating a beautiful setting with plenty of room for entertaining, recreation, and outdoor enjoyment.
1042 Amanda Lane, Gravenhurst
3
BEDS
1
BATHS
$1,395,000
FOR SALE
Tucked along the tranquil shores of Riley Lake, this is the kind of Muskoka property that quietly raises the bar. Set on an expansive 10.87 acres with 291 feet of pristine waterfront, and Crown land stretching across the lake, the privacy here is not just rare - it's absolute. Crafted in 2011 from trees harvested right on the land, the custom log home feels deeply connected to its surroundings. Inside, warm wood tones and an open-concept layout create an inviting, effortless flow. Two main-floor bedrooms offer comfort and convenience, while the open loft primary overlooks it all - your own peaceful retreat above the treetops. The exposure delivers long, golden afternoons and unforgettable summer sunsets. Down at the water's edge, the floating dock invites you into deep, clean water - perfect for swimming, paddling, or simply drifting the day away. This property was designed for how you actually want to spend your time at the lake. The finished 32' x 40' garage transforms into an all-season gathering space. The lakeside tiki bar brings a playful, relaxed energy. Evenings unfold in the sauna, by the firepit, or under a sky full of stars. A natural frog pond adds character and life to the landscape, while the fenced vegetable garden lets you bring fresh, homegrown flavour straight to the table. With previously approved site plans for a future bunkie and addition, there's room here to grow. A whole-home Generac generator provides peace of mind in every season. Accessed by a 7km seasonal road - with easy winter use by ATV or snowmobile - and the added convenience of seasonal waste collection at the end of the lane. This isn't just a cottage. It's a private, year-round escape where Muskoka unfolds exactly as it should - quiet, natural, and entirely yours.
1615 Canning Road, Gravenhurst
3
BEDS
3
BATHS
$1,249,000
FOR SALE
1615 Canning Road Gravenhurst Modern Luxury Meets Riverfront Charm on the Severn System: Welcome to your ultimate waterfront sanctuary. Nestled along the highly sought-after Severn River-just steps away from the historic Hamlet Swing Bridge. This spectacular, custom built, two story home offers the perfect blend of contemporary luxury and quintessential cottage living. Built less than 5 years ago, this fully finished, turnkey four season property is ready for you to move in, unpack and start making memories. The heart of the home is designed to frame the breathtaking surroundings. Step out onto the expansive front deck, your front row seat to one of the region's finest waterways. Whether you are sipping your morning coffee or hosting an evening dinner, you'll love watching the beautiful boats effortlessly navigate the historic river system. Step down to your private dock, where you enjoy deeded water access and deep water entry right at your dock's edge. Great for swimmers, boaters and water enthusiasts alike. Inside the home boasts a bright, modern layout spanning 2 full levels. The upper floor has a bright eat in kitchen with island, dinning room with walkout to front deck, 3 large bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. The great room with cathedral ceiling and expansive windows look out to front porch and river views. The lower level expands your living space, offering a bonus family room with fireplace, a games room and a third bathroom. No detail was overlooked in the construction, featuring top tier, high end mechanical systems that ensure year-round comfort, safety, and piece of mind. The Verdict: Whether you are looking for a sophisticated four season vacation retreat or a permanent waterfront home, 1615 Canning Road delivers modern reliability in a timeless Muskoka setting.
1743 North Muldrew Lake Road, Gravenhurst
3
BEDS
1
BATHS
$1,199,999
FOR SALE
Muldrew Lake Southwest-Facing Muskoka Retreat Wake up to breathtaking southwest lake views from this beautifully treed, park-like property on one of Muskoka's most sought-after recreational lakes. Perfectly positioned on a private road, yet just ten minutes from all the amenities Gravenhurst has to offer and only 90 minutes from the 401 and 400 this is four-season cottage living at its most accessible. The whole cottage has been renovated over the last couple years. Last year the washroom was renovated, the interior walls of all three bedrooms has new siding, the exterior of both the cottage and garage completely painted, Decks were re-built last year and painted. Roof on the main cottage and garage was re-done in 2015.Inside, soaring vaulted ceilings and an open-concept kitchen and living area create a warm, airy feel, while large windows frame stunning lake views from every angle. Rich natural wood finishes on the walls and ceilings add classic Muskoka charm, and a cozy fireplace makes autumn evenings something to look forward to. Step outside onto the cedar deck, where a covered section offers shade on sunny afternoons or can easily be screened in to create your own Muskoka room. A low-maintenance stone patio and level walkways connect the parking area directly to the cottage for easy everyday living. The terraced lot leads you down to the water's edge, where the lake beckons for all your favourite warm-weather pursuits. Three comfortable bedrooms provide plenty of room for family and guests, while a detached garage and workshop, plus a full perimeter block basement, offer generous storage for all your gear and toys. Quality furnishings are included, making this a true turn-key getaway pack your bags and start enjoying.
1005 Laidlaw Avenue, Gravenhurst
3
BEDS
3
BATHS
$1,195,000
FOR SALE
Welcome to "The River View," a custom-built Muskoka retreat that captures the best of both worlds - waterfront cottage enjoyment paired with the comfort and practicality of a year-round home. Thoughtful design and natural beauty come together in the great room, where soaring windows frame captivating views of the Severn River and a striking granite fireplace creates a warm focal point. With approximately 1,800 square feet of well-planned living space, the residence features 3 comfortable bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, offering both functionality and privacy for family and guests, while a versatile loft creates the perfect reading nook or quiet workspace. A detached garage adds exceptional flexibility with 500 square feet of finished space ideal for a home office, art studio, fitness room, or bunkie for guests and grandchildren. Outdoors, life on the river is defined by connection to nature and usability - explore more than 20 km of calm waters by boat or paddle, enjoy sought-after western exposure and stunning sunsets around the firepit, and unwind in true Muskoka fashion. Convenient access to Highway 11 and Washago ensures easy travel, with Gravenhurst and Orillia just 15 minutes away. As the closest Muskoka address to the GTA, properties offering this level of four-season waterfront living with effortless commuting access are increasingly in demand, making "The River View" a compelling opportunity to enjoy a relaxed cottage lifestyle without giving up the comfort and convenience of a full-time home. Click the Property Brochure link below for the virtual tour, floor plans, and additional photos.
1020 Amelia Crescent, Gravenhurst
3+1
BEDS
3
BATHS
$1,299,000
FOR SALE
Welcome to this exceptional custom-built family home set on 3 picturesque acres, complete with an impressive 2,400 sq. ft. heated shop - the perfect setup for hobbyists, tradespeople, entrepreneurs, or anyone craving space to live, work, and play. Ideally located just minutes south of Gravenhurst, with quick access to Highway 11, this property offers the perfect balance of convenience and peaceful country living in a quiet, tree-lined neighbourhood. Step inside the beautifully maintained brick home where soaring vaulted ceilings, expansive windows, and rich hardwood floors create a warm and inviting atmosphere filled with natural light. Designed with families in mind, the main floor features 3 spacious bedrooms, including a generous primary retreat with ensuite bath and walkout access to the outdoors. The fully finished lower level offers incredible versatility with a large additional bedroom, dedicated workout room or potential 5th bedroom, home office, full bathroom, and an expansive rec room perfect for entertaining, movie nights, or multi-generational living. A large utility/storage area and cold room add even more practical space. The welcoming main foyer includes a convenient powder room, main floor laundry, and direct walkouts to both the attached double garage and backyard. Outside, the beautifully landscaped grounds showcase mature trees, lush perennial gardens, and plenty of level parking for vehicles, trailers, or equipment. The standout detached shop opens the door to endless possibilities - ideal for contractors, car enthusiasts, woodworkers, storage, or home-based business operations. Located just a stone's throw from Kahshe Lake and cherished by the same family since its construction in 1990, this rare offering combines space, privacy, functionality, and lifestyle in one remarkable package. This is the one you've been waiting for!
1104 Xavier Street, Gravenhurst
3+2
BEDS
3
BATHS
$1,445,000
FOR SALE
Welcome to this exceptional Muskoka retreat offering a rare blend of luxury, privacy, and resort-style living on an expansive 1+ acre estate lot, with a total of 3,286 sq ft of finished living space. Step outside to your private backyard oasis featuring a heated saltwater pool, extensive stone landscaping, cabana, firepit, and a covered composite deck with retractable screened walls-creating a fully enclosed outdoor living space perfect for relaxing or entertaining in every season. A separate garden shed provides additional storage for tools and outdoor equipment. The extended paved driveway with rear garage access and a fully insulated, heated garage add both convenience and functionality. Inside, the home features 3 bedrooms on the main level along with 2 bathrooms and an elegant open-concept layout ideal for everyday living and entertaining. The heart of the home is a chef-inspired kitchen highlighted by a stunning 10' quartz island, perfect for gathering with family and friends. The fully finished lower level offers 2 additional bedrooms, a modern 3-piece bathroom, a dedicated dressing room/wardrobe, kitchenette, and a spacious recreation room, ideal for extended family, guests, or multi-generational living. Premium upgrades include dual-fuel heating (heat pump and propane), whole-home generator, in-ground irrigation, water filtration with reverse osmosis, and a professional smart security system with 11 cameras, extended WiFi, and smartphone monitoring. Located in a desirable established neighbourhood with convenient access to Highway 11 and just minutes from the amenities of Gravenhurst, Orillia, and Bracebridge, and close to Sparrow Lake and Kahshe Lake for boating, fishing, and year-round recreation.
1045 Tower Crescent, Gravenhurst
3+2
BEDS
3
BATHS
$1,299,000
FOR SALE
Escape the city without giving it up entirely. Tucked away on a beautifully landscaped 1.7-acre setting, this elevated raised bungalow offers a peaceful, cottagelike lifestyle less than two hours from the city. Approached by an expansive driveway framed by mature trees and natural vegetation, the sense of arrival is calm, private, and instantly grounding-with only one neighboring property in sight. Inside, the home feels bright, open, and welcoming, with oversized windows, cathedral ceilings, and propane fireplaces creating wonderful gathering spaces year-round. The heart of the home -the fantastic kitchen great room- flow effortlessly into a fabulous Muskoka three-season room, an inviting place to slow down, sip your morning coffee, or unwind while overlooking mature trees & beautiful Muskoka rock formations. Step out onto the maintenance-free composite deck and feel completely immersed in nature. Warm textures, rustic touches, and thoughtful finishes strike the perfect balance between comfort and understated luxury. The fully finished lower level offers exceptional flexibility with oversized windows, walkout access, and space ideal for extended family, guests, or future in-law or second-unit potential. A recreation area with bar & fireplace makes it perfect for relaxed entertaining. Designed for easy living, this bungalow includes extensive mechanical upgrades, backup generator, irrigation, security systems, & 200 amps-offering peace of mind and minimal utility costs. A large, insulated three-bay garage provides space for vehicles, hobbies, and weekend toys. Surrounded by granite outcroppings, perennial gardens, forested views, and soft evening lighting, this is a home where nature, comfort, and privacy come together-an everyday escape that feels worlds away yet remains close to everything. Perfectly positioned in Kilworthy, minutes to downtown Gravenhurst and approx. 20 mins to Orillia, with easy access to dining, shopping, healthcare, and year-round amenities.
DIALOG CONTENT
Would you like to receive Similar Listing Alerts as soon as they are uploaded to MLS®?
How would you rate our website?
Would you like to rate us on Google?
Yes
274746744